The Stitch That Can’t Be Learned

Scroll this

Editor’s Note: This is the sixth post in the Dwelling in Place series edited by Nicole Miller. You can read other posts in this series here. 


This story starts with an otherwise ordinary spring afternoon I spent with my grandmother, or Dadima, as she taught me a traditional Gujarati embroidery stitch. We lingered, knelt on the wood floors of her home as a story unfolded, of lands far away in the distant past emerged. We dwelled not only in her memories, but the ones embedded in the act of making.  While her knowledge of the tangible act of making perseveres, her notions of context, origin and place of craft are shaped by her own experiences of migration, distance, and adaptation. I supplement my conversation with Dadima with the work of fashion anthropologist Emma Tarlo as well as conversations with educators and artisans to understand a history lost only to some. Through Emma Tarlo’s work Clothing Matters when she was living among rural Gujarati artisans during India’s 1990s economic liberalization I found a sort of foreign intimacy with those who continue to preserve the craft of embroidery in villages, rooted in place. As well, by attending textile workshops, fuelled largely by a post-pandemic resurgence of textile craft and their increasing digital reach, I encountered a new mode of preserving craft, dispersed on the global stage.

There are two types of dwelling which frame this story. The first is the time spent in a diasporic home, learning that the ordinary architecture of a Canadian home over time becomes a witness to a longer history of migration, settlement, and re-making home over again. The second is dwelling in memory and the practice of making. Through acts of making we become part of a lineage of makers whose hands embroider, grounding us in distant places, times and environments. While many traditional motifs and techniques developed through intimate relationships with local ecologies, materials, and rhythms of rural life, as migration, industrialization, and global markets have transformed craft production, these environmental connections have often become obscured. Despite this, the stitch remains. This dislocation of craft only furthers the commercialization of embroidery, where craft is increasingly valued as a product rather than as a continued practice of dwelling in itself. By uncovering what we know, and what has been lost along the way, we ground ourselves not in one specific place, but in the space in between. 

The closet

We found her basket of embroidery supplies at the bottom of the hallway closet behind a basket for deep frying and atop a still unopened panini press. After all, that is where it lived in her memory—in the midst of cooking, cleaning, and laundry was craft. And so it was tucked away behind the mirror-clad sliding door, no longer needed with Joe Fresh, Temu, and Amazon which embellished clothes with such efficiency and variety that an expression of self had transformed into a commercial process of selection instead of creative production. 

Dadima teaching embroidery.
Photograph by the author (2026).

She took the wicker basket and opened it on the floor. We sat kneeling on the wood floors as she uncovered the layers of items: jars of thread, embroidery floss, needles packaged in local newspaper scraps. She pulled out a handful of royal blue embroidery floss still wrapped in gold paper she brought with her from East Africa to Canada forty years ago. At the bottom was a piece of bright pink cotton, a sampler of stitches she had learned when she was young. 

“This is called Marwari1 stitch” she told me, her fingers tracing lightly over the intertwining threads holding the geometric pattern together, “back home in Nairobi, Kenya” it was taught to her by a childhood friend. 

The sampler was meant to serve as a guide; three versions of the same stitch took up most of the fabric. In green the outline of the stitch, threads crossing at right angles to create clusters of squares, looping over and under each other and making it difficult to locate the beginning and end without looking at the back. The second wound the thread through the outline, never piercing the fabric, morphing the squares into points and filling in the negative space. The last version was another motif outline done in a thick red thread, incorrect  according to Dadima, who instructed that the thread should be proportional to the size of the stitch, and needle should be sharp, not “buttu”. 

When I asked her to teach me, she handed me the sampler and said she could not remember, having not touched it in over fifty years. So, over the next week I attempted to learn the stitch following the sampler. As I scrutinized the sampler, attempting to mimic the overs and unders, I shared with Dadima my progress, and as she corrected the proportions, order and stitch length of my amateur attempt, she too relearned the motif, remembering the act of making, if nothing else. 

The thorns of the babul tree
Image credit: Vachellia nilotica the “babul” tree thorns. Wikimedia Commons (2025).

I would come to find out Marwari was not one of the many names this stitch was known, though the general region was correct. Originating in Armenia as the Marash or Kaghdnagar stitch, which translates to “secret stitch”, the economical technique of interlacing thread was meant to be passed down like a secret, not simply learned from looking, but shared directly from person to person. It spread via travellers to the North-West of the Indian subcontinent, becoming widely adopted over generations in the Sindh (Pakistan) and Kutch (Gujarat, India) regions. Called Sindhi Taropa, Sindhi Kadhai, Kutch stitch, Bavariya Bharat2, and Kanta3, referencing the “gando baval” (translating to “mad tree”) or the Acacia nilotica “babul” tree, a native species to dry and arid regions of South Asia, the Arabian Peninsula, and parts of North and East Africa. The four points of the stitch took inspiration from the tree’s thorns, likely the part which remained after use in medicine, gum arabic, fodder, and roofing materials.

Two industrial landscapes

By the turn of the 20th century, the desert and grassland landscapes of northwestern India began to embrace global industrialization, the clacking sounds of the sewing machine and the tracks of new railways permeated the otherwise idyllic land.4 These technologies, which ranged from domestic to infrastructural scales enabled greater mobility between urban and rural regions, both for handicrafts to reach cities, and the ideas of western globalization to reach the village. Decorative motifs which emerged as reactions and in reference to local landscapes were adopted as “ethnic chic” by the urban elite, setting them apart from the onslaught of mass and machine produced garments of the post-industrial period. In film as well, regional styles were used as a means of characterizing piety and traditionalism in women, and embellishment techniques adopted personalities or  harmonized with set backdrops. 

Collage of mirror embroidery and illustration of Delhi market street where textiles and other goods were bought and traded.
Image credit: William Carpenter, Delhi. A Street at back of Jumma Musjid (1857). Collage with machine-done abhla embroidery by author.

On the other hand, ready-to-wear and machine embellished garments became increasingly popular throughout rural villages, representing an aspirational embrace of modernity and the wealth brought by industry. While symbols of flora, fauna and religious figures were abstracted into the costumes of film stars in Bombay, rural villages invented new symbols to adorn their garments, drawing from rumours of new technologies and lifestyles they could only imagine. As demand for artisan craft declined amidst the emerging ready-to-wear, and foreign-made synthetic fabrics, many artisans were forced to take up agrarian work or relocate to nearby cities to make a living. Those who remained appealed to a wider customer base through the invention of technology-related designs such as the radio, clock or train5, complete with mirrors (abhla) and traditional satin-stitched thread. Where crafts adopted by the urban film and fashion industries became valued for their aesthetic, rural production of embellishment maintained its relationship to its environment, even as it evolved in the face of the increasing pressures of globalization.  

Illustrated postcard of rail construction through rural landscape embroidered with motif of rail.
Image credit: National Railway Museum / Science & Society Picture Library. Embroidery by author; motif of rail documented by Tarlo (1996; p. 215).

In the diaspora

I learned this interwoven stitch from Dadima in her home of thirty years in Vancouver, doubly removed from an Indian origin, and even farther from wherever its true origin may lie. I marvel at the pink scrap of fabric’s journey; a piece of her own heritage carried with her as she migrated across East Africa amidst anti-Asian sentiments and to Canada where she and her family landed. To learn a stitch from afar, in both space and time, is to re-imagine the world in which it existed, and those who kept it alive over centuries, across borders, colonial rule, and global industrialization. And to learn it from person to person, as it was intended, speaks to a tradition which far outlives its connection to a specific environment and allows it to garner new meanings along the way. For an act as simple as looping thread through fabric, and winding around itself, the meditative act of embroidery allows us to feel a part of a lineage, of a practice which, from its origins, has continued to be mobile and adapt to those who continue it. 

Kutch stitch embroidered on photo of Dadima’s closet, where it was found.
Image credit: Image and Kutch stitch embroidery by author (2026).

Notes

1 Language commonly spoken by the Marwari people in the desert region of Rajasthan, near Jodhpur, not associated with a specific stitch or form of embroidery.

2 TATTER Kutch Embroidery Workshop with Shahnaz Khan, July 2026.

3 Emma Tarlo, Clothing Matters: Dress and Identity in India (The University of Chicago Press, 1996), 214.

4 David Arnold, “Global Goods and Local Usages: The Small World of the Indian Sewing Machine, 1875–1952,” Journal of Global History 6, no. 3 (2011): 415, https://doi.org/10.1017/S1740022811000398.

5  Tarlo, Clothing Matters, 217.


The following two tabs change content below.

Nisha Bhathella

Nisha Bhathella is a graduate student, designer and researcher. Her current practice explores the connection between textile craft, place, and placelessness through multi-scalar networks of migration and mobility. She is committed to the importance of diasporic storytelling in spatial discourse, and is currently pursuing her Masters of Architecture at the University of Waterloo.

Latest posts by Nisha Bhathella (see all)

NiCHE encourages comments and constructive discussion of our articles. We reserve the right to delete comments that fail to meet our guidelines including comments under aliases, or that contain spam, harassment, or attacks on an individual.